Quantum Foundations

In the de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory, an ensemble of fermions is not only described by a spinor,  but also by a distribution of position beables. If the distribution of positions is different from the one predicted by the Born rule, the ensemble is said to be in quantum non-equilibrium. Such ensembles, which can lead to an experimental discrimination between the pilot-wave theory and standard quantum mechanics, are thought to quickly relax to quantum equilibrium in most cases.   In this talk, I will look at the Majorana equation from the point of view of the pilot-wave theory and I will show that it predicts peculiar trajectories for the beables; they have to move luminally at all times and they usually undergo complex helical trajectories to give the illusion that their motion is subluminal. The nature of the Majorana trajectory suggests that relaxation to quantum equilibrium could only be partial and that quantum non-equilibrium could still survive at length scales below the Compton wavelength.  I investigate this claim, thanks to some numerical simulations of the temporal evolution of non-equilibrium distributions,  for three-dimensional confined systems governed by the Dirac and Majorana equations.

This talk presents two results on the interplay between causality and quantum information flow. First I will discuss about the task of switching the connections among quantum gates in a network. In ordinary quantum circuits, gates are connected in a fixed causal sequence.  However, we can imagine a physical mechanism where the connections among gates are not fixed, but instead are controlled by the quantum state of a control system. Such a "quantum switch" mechanism is consistent with quantum theory but cannot be described with in the standard model of causally ordered circuits, where it would be equivalent to a deterministic time travel and hence would violate the causality principle. With respect to the standard circuit model, the quantum switch is a new primitive that enables new information-processing protocols, such as the perfect discrimination between two classes of channels that are not perfectly distinguishable in a single query by any ordinary quantum circuit. Second, I will discuss about the probabilistic simulation of impossible channels that take an input in the future and produce an output in the past. In this case, I will show that the maximum probability of success in such a simulation is determined by causality and is inversely proportional to the amount of information that the channel can transmit.

The standard approach to quantum nonlocality (Bell's Theorem) relies on the assumption of the existence of "free will". I will explain how to get rid of this mysterious assumption in favor of the independence of sources. From this new point of view, Bell's Theorem becomes a statement about Bayesian networks. Besides allowing a more intuitive formulation of the standard result, our formalism also provides new network topologies giving rise to new kinds of nonlocality. Some of these relate to results by Steudel and Ay on the statistical inference of causal relations. Witnessing quantum nonlocality in new network topologies is a challenge which I will pose as an open problem.

We present a quantization method based on theEhrenfest theorem embedded in an extended algebraic structure capableof consistently describing hybrid quantum-classical systems, where thestandard quantum and classical mechanics are two limiting cases. TheWigner phase space formulation and the Schordinger equation are foundto be two alternative representations of the quantum case while theKoopman-von Neumann equation is the corresponding classicalcounterpart. Moreover, the developed quantization procedure isgeneralized to describe open systems, quantum/classical field theoriesand relativistic mechanics where new dynamical equations appear,shedding new light on important practical problems such asunderstanding of the quantum/classical transition and modeling ofmesoscopic systems.

Related references: arXiv:1105.4014, arXiv:1112.3679, arXiv:1107.5139

Categorical quantum mechanics (CQM) uses symmetric monoidal categories to formalize quantum theory, in order to extract the key structures that yield protocols such as teleportation in an abstract way. This formalism admits a purely graphical calculus, but the causal structure of these diagrams, and the formalism in general, is unclear. We begin by considering the signaling abilities of probabilistic devices with inputs and outputs and we show how a non-signaling device can become a perfect signaling device under time-reversal. This conflicts with the causal structure of relativity, and suggests that an `asymmetry' is needed when formalizing causality in CQM. We then show how a fixed causal structure within CQM corresponds to topological connectedness in the graphical language, and that correlations, either classical or quantum, force terminality of the tensor unit. We also show that well-definedness of a global state forces the monoidal product to be only partially defined, which in turn results in a covariance theorem. These structural results lead to a mathematical entity which we call a `causal category'.

I will present a new approach to information theoretic foundations of quantum theory, developed in order to encompass quantum field theory and curved space-times. Its kinematics is based on the geometry of spaces of integrals on W*-algebras, and is independent of probability theory and Hilbert spaces. It allows to recover ordinary quantum mechanical kinematics as well as emergent curved space-times. Unlike the approaches based on lattices of projections, this kinematics provides a direct mathematical generalisation of the ordinary probability theory to the regime of non-commutative algebras. The new quantum information dynamics is provided by the constrained maximisation of quantum relative entropy. The von Neumann-Lueders rule and several other rules of that type, including Bayes' rule in commutative case, are the special cases of it. Using Favretti's generalisation of the Jaynes-Mitchell source theory, I will show how this dynamics allows one to derive `interacting QFT'-like correlation functions and perturbation expansions in geometric terms of experimental control-and-response parameters, without using Hilbert spaces or measure spaces. Finally, I will present a new bayesian interpretation of quantum theory, aimed at dealing with the intersubjective experimental verifiability, but without providing any ontological claims. Quite noticeably, this interpretation leads to a concrete category theoretic formulation of the new foundations.

We prove an uncertainty relation for energy and arrival time, where the arrival of a particle at a detector is modeled by an absorbing term added to the Hamiltonian. In this well-known scheme the probability for the particle's arrival at the counter is identified with the loss of normalization for an initial wave packet. The result is obtained under the sole assumption that the absorbing term vanishes on the initial wave function. Nearly minimal uncertainty can be achieved in a two-level system.

The experimental violation of Bell inequalities using spacelike separated measurements precludes the explanation of quantum correlations through causal influences propagating at subluminal speed. Yet, it is always possible, in principle, to explain such experimental violations through models based on hidden influences propagating at a finite speed v>c, provided v is large enough. Here, we show that for any finite speed v>c, such models predict correlations that can be exploited for faster-than-light communication. This superluminal communication does not require access to any hidden physical quantities, but only the manipulation of measurement devices at the level of our present-day description of quantum experiments. Hence, assuming the impossibility of using quantum non-locality for superluminal communication, we exclude any possible explanation of quantum correlations in term of finite-speed influences.

It is my contention that non-commutative geometry is really "ordinary geometry" carried out in a non-commutative logic. I will sketch a specific project, relating groupoid C*-algebras to toposes, by means of which I hope to detect the nature of this non-commutative logic.